Bob Evans Potato Soup Recipe (Cheddar Baked Copycat)

There’s a reason the potato soup is the thing people order at Bob Evans when it’s cold out. It’s thicker than most restaurant soups — closer to a loaded baked potato that happens to be in a bowl — and it arrives under a pile of bacon, cheddar, and chives. This copycat Bob Evans recipe for potato soup gets you there with ingredients from one grocery run.

The version below is the cheddar baked potato soup from the menu, and it’s the Bob Evans potato soup recipe I’ve settled on after a lot of adjustment. Most of that adjustment was about thickness. Restaurant potato soup is thick, and almost every homemade version comes out thinner than the thing it’s imitating.

About 45 minutes, one pot, and it feeds six generously.

What Makes This Taste Like Theirs

Three details separate a recipe for Bob Evans potato soup from a generic creamy potato soup, and none of them costs anything.

Russets, and don’t be gentle with them. Russets break down as they cook, and that breakdown is your thickener. Waxy potatoes like red or Yukon Gold hold their shape, which sounds nicer but gives you potato chunks floating in thin broth. Mash about a third of the pot against the side with a spoon before the dairy goes in.

A real roux, not a cornstarch slurry. Flour cooked in the bacon fat gives the soup body and flavor. Cornstarch gives it a slightly slick texture and nothing else.

Sharp cheddar, off the block. Pre-shredded cheese is coated in anti-caking starch that keeps it from melting smoothly, and it’s the most common reason a homemade cheese soup turns grainy. Grate your own — it takes two minutes and it’s the difference between silky and broken.

About the Cheddar Baked Version

Bob Evans has run a few potato soups over the years, and the one people mean when they search for a Bob Evans cheddar potato soup recipe is the cheddar baked one: potatoes, sharp cheddar melted into the base, bacon, and sour cream, finished with green onion.

What makes it a baked potato soup rather than just potato soup is the toppings and the sour cream — it’s built to taste like a fully loaded baked potato. If you’ve been looking for a Bob Evans baked potato soup recipe specifically, this is that soup.

Ingredients

Thick-cut bacon: Fat becomes the roux base; crisped pieces go on top. Don’t use pre-cooked. Sub: 3 tbsp butter + ½ tsp smoked paprika for vegetarian.

Yellow onion: Savory base. Dice small. Sub: leeks, white and light green parts only.

Garlic: Add after the onion softens — one minute, or it burns. Sub: ¾ tsp garlic powder.

All-purpose flour: The thickener. Cooked in bacon fat so it loses the raw taste. Sub: 3 tbsp cornstarch in cold broth, added at the end, for gluten-free.

Low-sodium chicken broth: Bacon and cheddar bring plenty of salt. Sub: vegetable broth.

Russet potatoes: High starch, breaks down, thickens the soup. Sub: Yukon Gold, but mash more. Not red potatoes — they stay firm.

Whole milk: Creaminess without the weight of all cream. Sub: 2%. Not skim or non-dairy.

Heavy cream: The richness that makes it taste like the restaurant. Sub: half-and-half, or evaporated milk if your heat runs hot.

Sharp cheddar, grated from a block: Pre-shredded is starch-coated and makes soup grainy. Sub: extra-sharp, or half smoked gouda. Skip mild.

Full-fat sour cream: The tang that makes it baked potato soup. Sub: Greek yogurt, tempered first. Not low-fat — it curdles.

Kosher salt: Measured up front, adjusted at the end. Sub: table salt, cut by a quarter.

Black pepper: Freshly cracked, in the pot and on top.

Smoked paprika: Not in the original. Reinforces the bacon. Sub: omit for a closer copycat.

Green onions: Sharpness cuts the richness. Add at the end. Sub: chives.

How To Make Bob Evan’s Cheddar Baked Potato Soup

Step 1: In a large mixing bowl combine Cheddar cheese soup, chicken broth and whole milk. Mix until it is smooth and well combined.

Step 2: Add in cheddar cheese (if using pre-shredded your sauce may get clumpy) and stir just until melted and smooth. Keep stirring to avoid clumps.

Step 3: Melt butter in the pot, then stir cornstarch and cook until it is dissolved. Keep cooking, stirring occasionally, to let the soup thicken up to your liking.

Step 4: Add salt, black pepper, onion powder and garlic salt; mix well. Add more seasonings to taste, having the perfect flavor balance.

Step 5: Gently fold in the boiled, diced potatoes. Let it gently simmer for 5–10 minutes, so all the flavors can mingle and the potatoes can soak up the cheesy broth.

Toppings

The toppings aren’t optional — a loaded baked potato soup recipe is defined as much by what goes on top as what’s in the pot.

• Crisp bacon
• Extra sharp cheddar
• Green onions or chives
• A spoonful of sour cream

Optional but good: cracked pepper, a dash of hot sauce, or crushed kettle chips for crunch.

Slow Cooker Method

For a Bob Evans potato soup recipe crock pot version, the dairy still goes in at the end.

1. Cook the bacon, onion, garlic, and roux in a skillet, then transfer to the slow cooker.
2. Add the broth, potatoes, and seasonings. Low 6–7 hours or high 3–4, until the potatoes are tender.
3. Mash a third of the potatoes in the crock.
4. Stir in the milk, cream, cheese, and sour cream. Warm on low 20–30 minutes.

Adding dairy at the start will separate it over a long cook.

What to Serve With It

Warm buttermilk biscuits are the closest match to sitting in the restaurant, and herb butter dinner rolls are what I make when the soup is dinner.

For a bigger meal, a bowl alongside hand-breaded chicken tenders is the combination that gets ordered most.

If you’re working through the soup menu, Bob Evans chicken noodle soup is the lighter counterweight. And leftover home fries crisped up and dropped on top is better than it sounds.

Tips

• Cut the potatoes evenly or some turn to mush while others stay hard.
• Grate the cheese yourself — the biggest factor in silky versus grainy.
• Never boil after the dairy goes in.
• Salt at the end. Bacon, broth, and cheddar all contribute.
• It thickens overnight. Thin leftovers with milk.

FAQ

Why is my potato soup thin? Waxy potatoes, or you didn’t mash enough. Russets plus mashing a third of the pot is what makes it thick.

Why did my cheese soup turn grainy? Pre-shredded cheese, or too much heat. Grate from a block and stay below a simmer once the dairy is in.

Can I make this Bob Evans cheese potato soup ahead? Up to 3 days. Reheat gently with a splash of milk — it thickens a lot when chilled.

Can I freeze it? Not well. Potatoes go mealy and the base separates. Freeze the soup base before the dairy and cheese, then finish it fresh.

How many does it serve? Six as a main, eight as a starter.

Can I leave the skins on? You can, for a more rustic result. It won’t be as close to the restaurant version, which is smooth.

More Copycat Bob Evan’s Recipe

Bob Evans Sausage & Egg Breakfast Bowls Recipe

Bob Evan’s Pot Roast Recipe

Copycat Bob Evans Colonial Dressing Recipe

Bob Evans Style Buttermilk Biscuits

Bob Evans Chicken Noodle Soup Recipe

Bob Evan’s Mushroom and Onion Chopped Steak Recipe

Bob Evan’s Fried Chicken Copycat Recipe

Bob Evans Pumpkin Bread Recipe

Bob Evan’s Potato Recipe

Bob Evan’s Hand-Breaded Chicken Tenders Recipe

Bob Evan’s Country-Fried Steak Recipe

Don’t Forget To Pin!

Share Your Creations! Are you active on Facebook? Join our Air Fryer Recipes Group, where hundreds of thousands of Air Fryer enthusiasts gather and share your photos! I’m always thrilled to see what you’ve made.