Ninja Creami Arbys Orange Creamsicle Shake Recipe

Bring the Arby’s Orange Creamsicle Shake home, today we give you this easy Ninja Creami Arbys Orange Creamsicle Shake Recipe another delicious reason to earn its place on your counter. Creamy, citrusy, and crazy simple — this is one summer shake you’ll want on repeat!

If you’ve ever pulled into the Arby’s drive-thru just to grab their limited-time Orange Creamsicle Shake, you’re not alone. That sweet mix of orange soda and vanilla cream is pure nostalgia in a cup. But what if you could enjoy that same dreamy flavor anytime — without even leaving the house?

Thanks to the Ninja Creami, recreating the iconic Arby’s Orange Creamsicle Shake is not only possible, it’s ridiculously easy. This recipe combines just a handful of ingredients to deliver the same citrusy punch and creamy vanilla goodness you crave — but with fewer preservatives and more control over the sweetness and ingredients.

🍦 Why You’ll Love This Ninja Creami Orange Shake

• Just like Arby’s but made right in your kitchen
• Freezes overnight, spins in minutes for instant satisfaction
• Simple ingredients, totally customizable — add protein powder, reduce sugar, or make it dairy-free
• Perfect for summer cravings, after-school treats, or late-night sweet tooth emergencies

🛒 Ingredients Needed

• Orange juice – classic flavor and bright citrus flavor
• Whole milk or half & half and Heavy Cream– creamy base like Arby’s
• Granulated sugar – optional, depending on soda sweetness
• Vanilla extract- For added flavor.
• Whipped cream + orange zest (optional, for topping)

How To Make Ninja Creami Arbys Orange Creamsicle Shake Recipe

Step One: Pour the orange juice, milk, sugar, vanilla extract, and heavy cream into your Ninja Creami pint container and give it a quick stir. Chill the mixture in the fridge for about 30 minutes so the flavors meld and the sugar fully dissolves.

Step Two: Once it’s cold, toss in the ice cubes and run the Ninja Creami on the “Milkshake” or “Smoothie” setting until it’s silky smooth and frothy. Serve in chilled glasses and top with whipped cream if you’d like a little extra indulgence. Enjoy your cool, creamy Orange Creamsicle shake!

💡 Tips and Variations

• Want a lighter version? Use low-fat milk.
• Add vanilla protein powder before freezing for a creamy post-workout shake
• For a dairy-free option, try oat milk.
• Make it extra thick by adding 1 teaspoon of pudding mix

📦 Storage

Once spun, this shake is best enjoyed right away. You can refreeze, but texture may change slightly. To re-spin, add a splash of milk and use the Re-spin setting.

More Copycat Arby’s Recipes!

Arby’s Copycat Reuben Sandwich

Arby’s Brown Sugar Bacon BLT Recipe

Arby’s Bronco Berry Sauce Copycat Easy Recipe

Reheating  Arby’s Premium Chicken Nuggets In Air Fryer

Arby’s Three Pepper Sauce Recipe

Arby’s Tzatziki Sauce

Air Fryer Copycat Arby’s Beef and Cheddar Sandwiches

Homemade Arby’s Cherry Turnovers

Arby’s Steakhouse Onion Rings Copycat Recipe

Ninja Creami Jamocha Shake (Arby’s Copycat)

Arby’s Horsey Sauce Copycat Recipe

Don’t Forget To Pin!

Follow me on Instagram @forktospoon, Facebook at Fork To Spoon TikTok @forktospoon or Pinterest at @forktospoon and let me know how you liked this recipe and my other recipes