If you love Five Guys but don’t love the price tag, I’ve got you covered! I’ve spent a lot of time in my kitchen testing out the best copycat recipes so you can enjoy all that burger-joint goodness right at home — and honestly? These recipes might be even better than the real thing. From those iconic hot dogs split and crisped to perfection, to thick and creamy cherry milkshakes made right in your Ninja Creami, every single recipe on this list is easy, delicious, and totally worth making. I even snuck in a couple of McDonald’s classics because once you start building your own fast-food favorites at home, there’s really no going back! Whether you’re firing up the air fryer for a quick weeknight dinner or setting up a full burger bar for the family, these recipes are guaranteed to make burger night the best night of the week. Let’s get cooking!
1. Five Guys Hot Dog
Did you know the secret to a Five Guys hot dog is splitting it down the middle before cooking? I use my air fryer to get those edges unbelievably crispy and caramelized. Nestled in a toasted, buttered bun, this is the only way I make hot dogs now.
2. Ninja Creami Five Guy’s Cherry Milkshake
No burger night is complete without a thick, creamy shake. I use my Ninja Creami to whip up this cherry masterpiece that tastes exactly like the one from Five Guys. A splash of maraschino cherry syrup is my secret weapon for that authentic diner flavor.
3. Five Guy Burgers (Juicy and Delicious!)
When I don’t feel like standing over a hot griddle, my air fryer comes to the rescue for burger night. I grate a little cold butter right into the ground beef mixture to keep the patties incredibly juicy. It’s a foolproof method for a quick, satisfying burger fix.
4. Copycat Five Guys Cajun Fries Recipe
This Copycat Five Guys Cajun fries recipe is perfect for everyone who loves those perfectly seasoned, crispy French fries from the popular burger chain. With just a few pantry staples, 15 minutes of prep time, and your trusty Air Fryer, you’ll be able to make these in your kitchen! Serve them with a nice burger, team them up with your favorite sauces and dips or enjoy them as-is!
5. Five Guys Strawberry Milkshake
I couldn’t resist adding one more classic shake to the lineup. Using the Ninja Creami, I blend up a rich, nostalgic strawberry milkshake that perfectly balances out a salty, savory burger meal. It’s so thick and creamy, you’ll definitely need a spoon!
